Why Your Records

Are Not Selling

Five small changes that can turn stalled releases into steady momentum

If your records aren’t selling, it doesn’t automatically mean your label is failing — or that your music doesn’t matter.

More often, it’s a handful of small, fixable issues that quietly add friction between your releases and the people who want to support them.

Let’s break down five common reasons records stall, along with practical arguments for each.

You don’t need to fix everything at once. Pick one, make a small improvement, and let momentum do the rest.

1. You make it really hard

If people can’t quickly hear your music or easily figure out how to buy it, most of them won’t try very hard. Attention is fragile, and friction kills momentum.

  • Listening isn’t instant: Your music should be playable within seconds (Spotify playlist, Bandcamp player, YouTube embed). If someone has to search, you’ve likely lost them.

  • Buying isn’t obvious: Bandcamp links, store links, and release priorities should be front and center — not buried under old merch or outdated pages.

2. You’re not asking

Many labels assume that promotion alone equals selling. It doesn’t. Sales require clear, repeated, and unapologetic asks.

  • You’re talking to the wrong people: Press is important, but retailers, distros, wholesale buyers, and your own audience are the ones who actually purchase records. Build and nurture a buyer list.

  • One post is not a campaign: Sending one email or making one social post is passive. Labels sell by repeating the ask, clearly and confidently, over time.

3. Your package is unappealing

People don’t just buy music — they buy presentation, identity, and intent. The package signals whether something is worth paying attention to.

  • Artwork sets expectations: Before anyone hears a note, the cover art tells them what kind of experience they’re about to have. Weak visuals quietly say “this might not matter.”

  • The full campaign matters: Packaging, bundling, photos, copy, and rollout all work together. A great record with a half-thought-out campaign rarely performs well.

4. Your pricing structure is off

Price communicates value. Get it wrong in either direction and you create unnecessary resistance.

  • Too expensive creates hesitation: If your pricing is out of line with similar releases in your genre, buyers pause — and pausing often means abandoning the purchase.

  • Too cheap can reduce perceived value: Underpricing can make something feel disposable. Shipping costs, in particular, can be a dealbreaker if they’re not handled thoughtfully.

5. Your music isn’t interesting (yet)

This one stings, but it matters. Music can be technically good and still not compel anyone to care.

  • The artist may need time: Growth takes releases. Sometimes the second, fifth, or twentieth record is the one that connects. That’s normal.

  • “Good” isn’t enough: Music is subjective, but boring is surprisingly objective. Aim for interesting — something that invites curiosity, friction, or further investigation

WATCH THIS EPISODE

and catch other videos on our YouTube Channel

Summary:
Selling records isn’t about hacks, tricks, or turning your label into something it’s not. It’s about clarity, intention, and removing unnecessary barriers. Most of the time, people aren’t saying “no” to your music — they’re just getting stuck along the way.

Choose one of these five areas and make it 10% better this week.

Small changes compound.

And over time, those quiet improvements are what turn releases into real, sustainable momentum.

Helpful Articles for Record Labels

How to Make a Business Plan

Record Contract Template

How to Start a Record Label

Branding & Album Artwork

Releasing Music on Vinyl

Music Publishing for Labels

How to Make Cassette Tapes

Bandcamp Best Practices

RECORD LABEL

ACADEMY

The Complete A to Z of Building and Growing an Independent Record Label.

BEST VALUE

*

BEST VALUE *

RECORD LABEL

ACADEMY

Instant Lifetime Access to all our courses, books, and templates!

    • How to Start a Record Label (Online Course)

    • Record Label Marketing Strategies (Online Course)

    • Record Label Decision Tool (Online Course)

    • Profitable Record Label (Online Course)

    • All 10 Micro Courses

    • All 8 Micro eBooks

    • How to Start a Record Label (eBook)

    • Record Label Marketing Strategies (eBook)

    • Tons of bonus templates and extra resources

RECORD LABEL

ACADEMY

Instant Lifetime Access to all our courses, books, and templates!

    • How to Start a Record Label (Online Course)

    • Record Label Marketing Strategies (Online Course)

    • Record Label Decision Tool (Online Course)

    • Profitable Record Label (Online Course)

    • All 10 Micro Courses

    • All 8 Micro eBooks

    • How to Start a Record Label (eBook)

    • Record Label Marketing Strategies (eBook)

    • Tons of bonus templates and extra resources

Other Record Labels Podcast

Featuring interviews with…